i just adopted a begal from a rescue mission, he came from an abusive home where i guess they beat him every time he peed on the carpet, so they just left him outside all the time. Now were crate traning him. Ill take him out every hour on the hour, and he'll still pee and poop in his crate, or hell hold it in untill you go to bed, if he has to go when hes out of the crate after he went outside he hides and goes where you cant see him, so we started rewading him when he goes out side and leting him stay out a little wile afterwrds, but then hell go in his cage still. What can i do to stop this. I know there very smart, but very stubborn. Thanks for your help.
sarah-

Optional Information:
Age: 1; Male; Breed: begal

Already Tried:
crate traning, walking every hour on the hour, praise when going potty, treats when going potty. still poops where noone sees him, or holds in in untell we go to sleep, and poops in the crate